Using I-Messages is not “all about you,” but it is about how to communicate appropriately and respectfully with others.
I-Messages communicate your feelings and perspectives in a respectful, less challenging way when:
- your child’s attitude or behavior is unacceptable to you
- you are trying to modify another’s behavior or attitude
- you own a problem involving another person
The 6-step formula of an effective I-Message
The most effective I-Message is clear and specific.
- State the specific, objective facts…no generalizations or zingers.
Example:
We agreed last week you would feed the dog every night by 5:00. Last night she did not get her dinner until after 8:00.
- State your feelings without attacking, judging, criticizing, or ascribing motives.
Example:
I feel disappointed when I discover the dog has not been fed. I feel sad for her.
- Describe the actual or potential negative impact.
Example of actual impact:
As a result, I don’t feel like I can trust you to feed her. I don’t like feeling this way about you.
Example of potential impact:
When you tell me you will feed the dog and then don’t do it, it makes it hard for me to trust you the next time you make a promise.
- Provide a fair request; describe the behavior that would correct the situation, making sure the request is reasonable for this specific child. Be clear and specific.
Example:
I expect you to feed her by 5:00 every night, and for the next week I would like you to tell me when you have fed her so there is no question in my mind.
- Describe a positive impact.
Example:
Once I know you can do this every night on time without a reminder from me, I will be able to trust you more for this and other times you make a promise.
- Request feedback; Listen respectfully and appreciate perspectives. Accept explanations, challenge excuses.
Example:
Would you like to tell me how you feel about this?
Example of responding to an explanation:
I hear that the time just got away from you and that you are really sorry that you did not carry out your commitment.
Example of challenging an excuse:
I understand that people sometimes forget to do things they promised to do, however when that happens, they need to correct their mistake and accept responsibility for making it.
I-Messages work better with reasoning of older children
As you can see, an I-Message is used within consideration of the age and stage of development of your child.
So, a toddler who does not yet have the capability to reason would not be the target of an I-Message that expects him to change.
The perfectly normal yet difficult to cope with behaviors such as impulsive and aggressive hitting, biting and throwing of objects may need more limit-setting responses from parents than the use of I-Messages.
Since in an I-Message you state what you are thinking and feeling, a father experiencing frustration over a toddler’s age-appropriate negative behavior can use an I-Message to vent without expecting that the toddler change. “I am so annoyed that I cannot be on the phone for even one minute without you touching things that are dangerous because I can’t finish my phone business.”
You-Messages
Destructive “You” messages are used by the speaker to put-down the child or control him. “You never listen,” or, “You should have set your alarm to remind you,” can diminish self-confidence and the health of the relationship.
These messages do not build your child’s Iceberg.
On the other hand, in your executive role as parent, it is often appropriate to use a take-charge message. Therefore, for reasons of your child’s safety, or when you assume the role of disciplinarian and speak from authority, a “you” message may be appropriate.
“You are going to do this my way now because I am the parent, and this is not open for discussion or negotiation at this moment.” This stance of being in charge is healthy and appropriate when a child needs help through an external control.
At times you may use you-messages with the teaching hat. This kind of message becomes appropriate when you provide information or explain values.
Such interactions are appropriate and valuable for you and your child. It is also both reasonable and necessary for you to convey, in a non-threatening way, the potential consequences of your child’s behavior: “If you pull the kitty’s tail, I will take her out of the room because in our family, we do not hurt our pets.”
PARENTING ACTION STEPS:
- Define the problem
- Determine who owns the problem
- Consider the desired outcome
- Communicate your perspective without attacking, blaming, accusing or taking control
Expert information from IPED
This information is brought to you by Lakeside Educational Network’s IPED Program. The Institute for Professional and Educational Development Program informs, equips and inspires educators, counselors, early childhood practitioners and human services professionals dealing with many difficult and complex issues each day.
Our exclusive curriculum, available directly from Lakeside’s IPED, is comprehensive in topics that promote emotional and relational health in children and families. Successful outcomes consistently occur as a result.
With more than 50 years of outstanding service through its many programs, Lakeside is proud to be an international advocate and resource for kids and families.
© All rights reserved, Diane Wagenhals, IPED, 2009.
If you would like to subscribe to our parenting tips, please follow us on Twitter at GerryatLakeside
If you’d like to learn more about our professional development training and CEUs, please complete the form below.
